On January 27, 2026, the Livingston Zoning Board of Adjustment met at 7:00 p.m. with ten applications for new single-family houses on its agenda. The addresses were spread across town: Yorktown Terrace, Cedar Parkway South, Brayton Road, West Cedar Street, Carlisle Drive, West McClellan Avenue, Burnet Hill Road, Highland Drive, Locust Place and Hazelwood Avenue. LLCs and builders filed nine of the ten, and the Rodak name appeared on three.
That night was typical for Livingston. The town is one of the most active rebuilding markets in North Jersey, even though its finished new homes sell for much less than those in Short Hills or Summit. Price explains it. Between 2019 and mid-2026, a Livingston builder has paid about a third of the eventual new-home price for the starting lot, a smaller share than in Westfield, Chatham, Summit or Short Hills. For a buyer comparing towns, that share puts both the older houses and the new construction in Livingston in context.
The Price of the Starting Lot
The North Jersey Teardown Report, updated in September 2026, matches state deed records from 2019 through June 2026 to state parcel data. It counts a lot as a teardown when a builder bought it and the parcel now shows a house built in 2019 or later. Of the 90 towns it covers in Essex, Morris, Union, Somerset and Bergen counties, Livingston ranks second, with 125 lots rebuilt during that period. Westfield, with 139, is the only town ahead of it.
Between 2019 and June 2026, builders paid a median of $533,000 for those Livingston lots. The 42 replacement houses that have resold so far sold at a median of $1.62 million, and the median time from builder purchase to new-home sale was 19 months. The report says clearly that the difference between purchase and resale is not profit, because demolition, construction, permits, financing and selling costs all come out of it.
The Ratio Says More Than the Median
The median sale price on a portal tells you what a typical Livingston house costs. The relationship between these two medians tells you something else: what the town's land is worth to the people who build on it, compared with what they can sell when they finish. The report's town table makes that comparison possible across this part of New Jersey.
| Town | Median builder purchase, 2019 to June 2026 | Median new-home resale | Purchase as a share of resale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Livingston | $533K | $1.62M | about 33% |
| Short Hills & Millburn | $1.25M | $3.54M | about 35% |
| Summit | $940K | $2.7M | about 35% |
| Chatham | $760K | $1.96M | about 39% |
| Westfield | $700K | $1.7M | about 41% |
Each pair of figures compares medians of two different groups of sales, so the percentages are approximate. The order is still clear. Between 2019 and June 2026, a builder in Westfield paid about 41 cents of every finished-home dollar for the starting lot, while a builder in Livingston paid about 33 cents. In dollar terms, the Livingston builder bought in at $167,000 less than the Westfield builder and resold at $80,000 less.
That gap goes a long way toward explaining why Livingston has nearly as many rebuilt lots as Westfield, and more than twice as many as Chatham, which had 57 over the same period. Short Hills and Summit sit near Livingston's ratio, but their median lots cost $1.25 million and $940,000, a much higher entry price. Those two towns had 41 and 25 rebuilt lots. Livingston combines a low share with a low entry price.
The Streets on the 2026 Agendas
The January agenda shows who was filing to build that winter. Susanna Property LLC filed for 13 Yorktown Terrace. Verdant Place LLC filed for 16 Cedar Parkway South. Square Group Realty, LLC filed for 75 W. Cedar Street, and PNC Developers, LLC filed for 14 Burnet Hill Road. Rodak Homes, Inc. filed for 23 Carlisle Drive, and Rodak Builders, LLC filed for 15 Highland Drive and 12 Locust Place. LLCs named after their addresses filed for 6 Brayton Road and 41 W. McClellan Avenue.
By July 30, 2026, the Board's agenda listed six more new-house applications, at 1 Avon Avenue, 38 Ross Road, 46 West Lawn Road, 3 Spalding Drive, 320 E. Cedar Street and 3 Tiffany Drive. Rodak Builders filed the West Lawn Road and Spalding Drive applications. Across the two agendas, Rodak filed for five houses, more than any other applicant.
The filings span the R-1 zone on Brayton Road, the R-2 zone on Locust Place and the R-4 zone that covers most of the others. In 2026 the new-house filings came from several of the town's residential zones, not from a single section of Livingston.
What Replaces the Older House
Builders' own project pages show the kind of house that replaces an older one. New Jersey General Contractors & Builders lists a 2024 to 2025 custom home at 17 Belvedere Drive with about 6,000 square feet of living space, plus a 3,000-square-foot finished basement, six bedrooms and six and a half baths. The same builder lists a 2024 to 2025 project at 60 Baker Road with about 6,793 square feet of livable space.
Houses of that size help explain the spread between the report's two medians. A lot bought near the town's median and finished as a six-bedroom house reaches a different part of the market from the house that stood there before. For a design-minded buyer, the difference goes beyond price. The new Livingston house is a large, finished, builder-specified product, and the older house is a structure on a lot that its next owner will shape.
The Next Year Is Already Underway
The teardown report's 19-month median gives a rough schedule for the work now in progress. At that pace, a lot bought by a builder in spring 2025 would reach the resale market around the end of 2026. The report says most purchases made after 2023 have not been rebuilt yet, so its counts for recent years run low. The new-house applications on the January and July 2026 agendas are part of that unfinished group.
The Township Council has also acted on rebuilding this year. On February 9, 2026, the council unanimously introduced an amendment to the Trees chapter that officials said would encourage builders to replant. Citizen Portal reported that public commenters at that meeting asked the town to track trees removed during development. On September 14, the council introduced Ordinance 32-2026, which creates a new R-4A Single-Family Zone District, with all five members present voting yes, according to Citizen Portal.
Choosing Between Livingston and Its Neighbors
For a buyer deciding among Livingston, Westfield, Chatham and Summit, the ratio adds a second measure to the price of a Livingston house. Between 2019 and June 2026, builders bought Livingston lots at a median of $533,000, compared with $700,000 in Westfield and $760,000 in Chatham. When an older Livingston house comes to market, the people bidding on it can include builders as well as families.
For finished homes, Livingston's $1.62 million median for new houses is close to Westfield's $1.7 million and below Chatham's $1.96 million. A buyer who wants a new house in this group of towns will find that Livingston's builders started from a lower land price, and that the town has more recently rebuilt lots than any town on that list except Westfield.
If you own an older Livingston house, the same figures raise a different question: where your house sits between its value to a builder and its value to a family who will live in it. A home valuation is the place to start, and our Livingston neighborhood guide covers the town beyond its new construction.
A Few Direct Questions
How does Livingston's rebuilding compare with nearby towns? From 2019 through June 2026, Livingston had 125 rebuilt lots, compared with 139 in Westfield, 57 in Chatham, 41 in Short Hills and Millburn, 25 in Summit and 16 in New Providence.
How long does a Livingston rebuild take to reach the market? For lots tracked from 2019 through June 2026, the median time from a builder's purchase to the sale of the new house was 19 months.
Is the gap between what builders paid and what they sold for their profit? No. The report states that demolition, construction, permits, financing and selling costs all come out of that difference.
Choosing between an older Livingston house and a finished new one is a design decision as much as a pricing decision. At Shannon Xavier, we look at the lot, the house and the numbers together before you make an offer on either. Schedule Your Concierge Consultation.